Costelloe's Food Menu
Explore Our Menu
Note to all Pizza lovers: Our most popular base ingredients are Italian sausage and pepperoni…..and we don’t skimp on those. Did you know that on a 16” pizza we apply a ½ pound of sausage and 55 slices of pepperoni? On a 14” pizza a ⅓ pound of sausage and 42 slices of pepperoni, and on a 12” pizza a ¼ pound of sausage and 22 slices of pepperoni. WOW! So, keep in mind that our pizzas may be slightly more expensive than others. However, we cannot skimp on our base meats and toppings and still call it a J.T.’s pizza.
Includes ranch or blue cheese with your choice of one flavor:
6 Wings- $8.75 | 12 Wings- $17.50 | 18 Wings- $26.25
10 Wings- $8.00 | 16 Wings- $12.80 | 22 Wings- $17.60
No Heat Flavors:
Garlic Parmesan | Sweet BBQ | Smokey Dry Rub | Parme-Q (Sweet BBQ mixed with our garlic parmesan)
Original Buffalo | Super-Hot Buffalo | Sweet Chili (Mild) | Tommy Style
Chili Cheese Fries $7.99
French fries topped with our homemade chili & J.T.'s beer cheese sauce.
Garlic Cheese Toast $6.49
2 pieces of French bread, toasted with JT’s garlic sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese & oregano, baked and served with marinara sauce.
Fried Dill Pickles $7.49
15 breaded & deep fried pickle chips served with JT’s homemade ranch dressing.
Pretzel Pub Kabobs $7.89
14 light & fluffy pretzel bites served on skewers with our homemade cheese sauce or the sauce of your choice on the side.
Luck of the Irish Dip $8.39
Also known as spinach artichoke dip, this delicious spread is served with made to order, homemade tortilla chips.
Tavern Taters $8.69
French fries topped with bacon, JT’s original wing sauce & melted cheddar cheese, served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.
J.T.’s Bowls & Plates
JT’s award winning Tavern style chili. Bowl- $6.50 | Cup- $4.50 Add cheddar cheese or chopped onions- $0.75 each
JT’s secret recipe meat sauce, served with a buttered roll. For all you vegetarians, ask for marinara instead of meat sauce. Add a jumbo meatball for $2.50.
Chili Mac $9.99
Spaghetti noodles topped with JT’s chili and served with a buttered roll. Add cheddar cheese or chopped onions- $0.75 each
- Shoes $9.99
Toast topped with ingredients of your choice, covered with fries & JT’s homemade beer cheese sauce. Burger | Ham | Grilled Chicken (Sliced & Marinated) Breaded Chicken | Breaded Buffalo Chicken
Additional Ingredients- $2.00 each
Italian Beef or Bacon Shoe $10.19
Emerald Isle Salad $9.99
Fresh baby spinach topped with sun dried tomatoes, red onion, pepperoncinis, and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house made creamy Italian dressing on the side. Add our marinated grilled chicken- $3.50
County Cork Side Salad $5.00
Build your own salad: Iceburg lettuce, mozzarella cheese & tomato. Additional veggie toppings at no charge: mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, green olives. Dressings: House Italian | Buttermilk Ranch | Blue Cheese | French | Honey Mustard | Poppy Seed
All baskets are served with fries or substitute a side salad for $1.99. All burger baskets are served with lettuce, tomato, pickle & onion on the side.
J.T.’s Grand Burger $12.29
2 smashed and seared ⅓ pound beef patties, stacked on a toasted bun with a triple dose of JT’s signature smoked cheddar cheese.
J.T.’s Double Burger $11.29
2 smashed and seared ⅓ pound beef patties, stacked on a toasted bun. Add a triple dose of cheese for $1.00 American | Pepper jack | Mozzarella | Swiss | Cheddar
J.T.’s Single Burger $10.29
1 smashed and seared ⅓ pound beef patty, served on a toasted bun. Add a double dose of cheese for $0.75 American | Pepper jack | Mozzarella | Swiss | Cheddar Try Smoked Cheddar for $0.85
J.T.’s Turkey Burger with Spicy Rub $10.99
A seared and seasoned turkey patty dusted with our house made 6 pepper blend rub. Served on a toasted bun. Add a double dose of cheese for $0.75 American | Pepper jack | Mozzarella | Swiss | Cheddar Try Smoked Cheddar for $0.85
Italian Beef Sandwich $11.49
Slow roasted, shaved, Chicago style beef piled on top of toasted French bread with au jus on the side. Add your choice of cheese for $0.75 American | Pepper jack | Mozzarella | Swiss | Cheddar Try Smoked Cheddar for $0.85
Hot Ham & Cheese $10.49
Thinly shaved ham & melted mozzarella cheese on toasted bread with a side of buttermilk ranch.
Meatball Sandwich $10.99
3 Jumbo meatballs on warmed French bread, covered in marinara sauce. Add your choice of cheese for $0.75
Southern Fried Wing Basket $13.50
5 Jumbo wings breaded in our signature family recipe breading. Comes with a toasted, buttered roll, fries, & cottage cheese. Please allow about 15 minutes to cook.
Buffalo Chicken Filet Sandwich $10.49
2 Breaded & fried chicken tenders tossed in your choice of Original Buffalo or Super-Hot wing sauce, covered with melted mozzarella cheese on toasted French bread and served with a side of ranch.
The Chicago Combo Sandwich $12.99
An old favorite! Slow roasted, shaved, Chicago style beef & our own Italian sausage piled on top of toasted French bread with au jus and marinara sauce on the side. Add your choice of cheese for $0.75 American | Pepper jack | Mozzarella | Swiss | Cheddar Try Smoked Cheddar for $0.85
Shrimp Basket $15.00
10 Battered & fried fantail shrimp served with a buttered roll, fries, & cottage cheese. Also served with cocktail sauce.
OUR FAMOUS PIZZAs
Design your very own pizza or choose from one of our specialty pizzas
J.T.’s Sauces – Red Tomato Sauce | Alfredo Garlic Sauce | Sweet BBQ Sauce
Toppings – Italian Sausage | Breakfast Sausage | Hamburger | Ham | Pepperoni | Bacon | Italian Beef | Grilled Chicken | Banana Peppers | Pepperoncinis | Green Olives | Black Olives | Minced Garlic | Green Peppers | Red Onions | Fresh Mushrooms | Sun-dried Tomatoes | Jalapenos | Pineapple | Tomatoes | Fresh Spinach | Feta Cheese
J.T.’s Two-Ply Pizza
2 Layers of thin crust, stacked on top of each other with a braided crust. Create your own Two-ply or chose from one of J.T.’s Specialty Pizzas. Comes with a choice of sauce: all Red Tomato Sauce, all Alfredo Garlic, or Both! J.T. recommends trying BOTH sauces!
Cheese Two-Ply Pizza-$14.50| Topping Add-Ons-$2.25 each
J.T.’s Specialty Pizzas
Only one substitution please: Meat for Meat or Veggie for Veggie
Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions & Green Peppers 12”- $15.50 | 14”- $18.50 | 16”- $22.50 | 2-Ply- $23.25
The Meat Lovers
Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Ham & Bacon 12”- $15.75 | 14”- $18.75 | 16”- $22.75 | 2-Ply- $24.00
The Shamrock Pizza
Fresh baby spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, bacon, red onion, & feta cheese. 12”- $18.00 | 14”- $22.25 | 16”- $26.25 | 2-Ply- $24.50
Grilled chicken, fresh baby spinach, banana peppers & alfredo garlic sauce. 12”- $16.00 | 14”- $19.75 | 16”- $23.50 | 2-Ply- $21.95
Sweet BBQ sauce, hamburger, green peppers & onions. It’s a backyard BBQ for your tastebuds! 12”- $14.00 | 14”- $17.25 | 16”- $20.75 | 2-Ply- $20.00
Italian Beef Pizza
Italian beef, pepperoncinis, & Chicago hot peppers. 12”- $14.00 | 14”- $16.75 | 16”- $20.75 | 2-Ply- $22.00
J.T.’s Kids Menu
J.T. Costelloe’s offers a full sit-down bar. If you choose, you may order and eat at the bar while enjoying your favorite sports on 5 different televisions. We stock most domestic and some specialty beers & seltzers. We also offer Smithwicks, an Irish beer, on draft which is our trademark.